Auto Repair

State Emissions & Inspections

Mechanic using computer diagnostics tool

Vehicle Diagnostics

Brakes

Fleet Maintenance

Oil Changes

Tires

Air Conditioning

Honest, Reliable Auto Repair in York, PA

Your Dealership Alternative for Expert Vehicle Care
Welcome to Witmer Automotive, York’s trusted home for honest mechanics and high-quality auto repair. We believe you shouldn’t have to choose between affordability and expert service. As a NAPA AutoCare Gold Certified shop, we offer the technical expertise of a dealership with the personal touch and fair pricing of a local, family-owned business.

Whether you need a quick oil change, a PA state inspection, or complex engine diagnostics, our certified technicians keep your vehicle running safely and smoothly. We serve drivers across York, West York, East Manchester, and North Yorkwith transparent service that puts you back in the driver’s seat.

Why York Drivers Choose Witmer Automotive

We take the stress out of car repair. Our commitment to transparency means no surprise bills and no unnecessary upsells—ever.

NAPA Gold Warranty: Drive with confidence knowing you are backed by our industry-leading 36-month/36,000-mile warranty on qualifying repairs.

Digital Vehicle Inspections: We don't just tell you what’s wrong; we show you. We send detailed reports with photos directly to your phone so you can make informed decisions.

Convenience First: We value your time. Enjoy our free pickup and delivery service (within service area) or our complimentary shuttle to get you where you need to go while we work.

See What Our Customers Are Saying!

					We’re from Pgh and sail the Chesapeake. Since we needed 2 cars inspected that were in Balt, I found Witmer’s to be close for us. Brian we great and scheduled the inspections. he communicated with us and even gave us some recommended work to be done at next service interval. Had a great lunch at the Cove while waiting 
read moreread less
Charles M
Feb 2025
					Fair man gives you the notes that need done to your car. Gives you the opportunity too fix the problem yourself cannot be mad one bit. Def will be back appreciate the business I had a inspection done btw
read moreread less
David Ortiz
Nov 2024
					Highly recommend! Witmer does a great job at taking care of my car. Convenient amenities like pickup and drop off. They make sure that you not only understand the services they are recommending, but why and the mechanics behind it. Very knowledgeable staff.
read moreread less
Christina Falicki
Oct 2024
					Friendly, accurate, and great pricing. Highly recommend!
read moreread less
Ryan Wert
Sep 2024
					I can not thank Brian and his team enough. It's hard to find shops in the area well knowledgeable about diesels unless you want to go straight to the dealer. It started as a Alternator problem and quickly the truck spiraled into a fuel issue less than 24 hours after the alternator was done. To no fault of theirs. They kept me in the loop every step of the way and worked with my secondary warranty company to help get some costs covered. To my surprise it was done a few days later. I didn't expect to see it for another week! I will definitely continue to use Witmers for anything my truck needs from oil changes to larger repairs. Thank you guys so much for your help, knowledge, and very quick timeliness! You will always be a recommendation!
read moreread less
Saphron Bullock
Sep 2024
					Had a quick emergency where my vehicle was giving a “engine overheating warning.” I was able to bring my vehicle in to Witmer without an appointment to get a diagnostic done. Though I had to wait a bit…I’m glad Witmer was able to squeeze me in to run the diagnostic which they addressed the problem with the error message and was able to provide an answer to the problem without breaking the wallet. Unfortunately, the problem was bigger than I thought but the staff was honest and upfront about the repairs and provided me with some useful information to get it resolved. KUDOS to Bryan and the mechanic Tony for helping me out in a short time period and for great customer service and hospitality. I definitely recommend this location for any vehicle service you may need!
read moreread less
Y B
Sep 2024
					I called just to ask a few questions and had the best experience. gave me information that I needed and was very helpful. I definitely recommend!!!!
read moreread less
Laura Hill
Sep 2024
					This place is the best place to bring your automobile for repairs. The owner Brian is very knowledgeable and professional. Honest and on time. They treat you like your the only one. Everything was top notch. I will not take my vehicles anywhere else. They are the best.
read moreread less
Bernard Martel
Aug 2024
					While traveling through the mountains on our vacation, we found ourselves in the city of York and desperately needed a brake job. Whitmer Automotive could not have been more accommodating, understanding of our concern of our timeline or professional. The owner Brian even gave us a ride to and from the mall so we didn’t have to “sit around” and wait. We highly recommend this establishment! Thank you to the Brian and Joe. You have saved our vacation!
read moreread less
Ken Close
Aug 2024

View All Reviews

Our Core Auto Repair Services

We service all makes and models, from domestic daily drivers to foreign imports and heavy-duty fleet vehicles.

PA State Inspection & Emissions

We are an official PennDOT inspection station. Our team performs thorough safety and emissions testing to ensure your car is legal and safe for Pennsylvania roads.

Brake Repair & Service

Squeaking brakes or a soft pedal? We provide comprehensive brake services, including pad replacement, rotor resurfacing, and fluid flushes to ensure stopping power when you need it most.

Engine Diagnostics & Check Engine Lights

Don't ignore that warning light. We use state-of-the-art diagnostic tools to pinpoint the exact cause of your engine issues—from misfires to sensor failures—saving you money on guesswork.

Fleet Maintenance

Keep your business moving. We offer prioritized fleet services to minimize downtime for local York businesses.

Schedule Your Service Today

Experience the difference of a mechanic who treats you like family. Stop by our shop in York, PA, or schedule your appointment online today.

(717) 481-3104

Visit Our Location
1512 S George Street
York, PA 17403

Auto Repair

State Emissions & Inspections

Vehicle Diagnostics

Brakes

Fleet Maintenance

Oil Changes

Tires

Air Conditioning

Honest, Reliable Auto Repair in York, PA

Why York Drivers Choose Witmer Automotive

NAPA Gold Warranty: Drive with confidence knowing you are backed by our industry-leading 36-month/36,000-mile warranty on qualifying repairs.

Digital Vehicle Inspections: We don't just tell you what’s wrong; we show you. We send detailed reports with photos directly to your phone so you can make informed decisions.

Convenience First: We value your time. Enjoy our free pickup and delivery service (within service area) or our complimentary shuttle to get you where you need to go while we work.

See What Our Customers Are Saying!

Our Core Auto Repair Services

PA State Inspection & Emissions

Brake Repair & Service

Engine Diagnostics & Check Engine Lights

Fleet Maintenance

Schedule Your Service Today